Cities and Climate Change in Coastal Western Indian Ocean A Grand Challenge (CICLICO)
Keywords
Country Covered
Cities, Climate Change, WIO region,
South Africa
Lead Institution
Project Duration
Nelson Mandela University and German Climate Service Center (GERICS)
2019-2021
Abstract
The growth of urban areas that form coastal cities, especially in the WIO, places an increasing demand on natural coastal extractive and non-extractive resources. The use and conversion of coastal land and catchments is considered a permanent effect of growth and development. Coastal cities, as a form of local government, represent growth and development priorities in the WIO and lie at the epicentre of the opportunities and challenges presented. These will be explored as a case study in the medium-sized coastal city of Port Elizabeth in the Nelson Mandela Bay municipality on the shores of Algoa Bay, South Africa.
The aim of CICLICO is to explore and plan, with decision-makers and society in the city of Port Elizabeth, how diverse and often uncoordinated objectives of coastal and marine planning can be implemented to enable better adaptation to climate change in vulnerable coastal cities of the WIO through the use of climate services for city planning tools.
This will result in an understanding of the use of area-based management approaches, governance perspectives, environmental assets and stakeholder conflicts in light of climate change. Systems dynamics modelling will support the understanding of a complex system challenged by wicked problems. Understanding the drivers and mechanisms of possible change on area-based management that is dynamic will allow for discussion and validation of the models and the development of climate services. Finally, climate services are intended to provide custom-designed and userdriven climate change data and information for use in decision-making and to explore the type and nature of climate services to support coastal and marine planning tools of cities in the WIO. Algoa Bay will be framed in a socio-ecological framework. This is motivated by the complex socio-political, economic and environmental systems and complicated managements strategies in which the area is embedded.
CICLICO is structured around three interrelated research work packages (WP) aligned with the project objectives. WP1 “Climate change and governance context” describes the Algoa Bay system, identifies the main climate change impacts on the port city and assesses the status quo, character and modus operandi of the existing coastal governance framework drawing on existing data, desktop reviews and expert interviews. WP2 “Participatory systems analysis and modelling” will engage with stakeholders using tools such as fuzzy cognitive mapping (FCM) to gain insight into stakeholder perceptions of coastal-sea area-based management in light of climate change, and system dynamics modelling (SDM) to identify leverage points, data and governance requirements to effectively address climate change. WP3 “Co-design of climate services” will define criteria for climate services drawing on stakeholder needs expressed in WP2 and knowledge of the climate change and governance context acquired in WP1. The recognition of the use of climate services can have a major impact on how and what climate data and projections inform ICM, MSP and MPAs. The creation of cross-sectoral and departmental city institutions to achieve unified objectives for coastal and marine management would be an indicator of the contribution of impact of CICLICO.
The co-implementation of ICM, MSP and MPAs are innovative and could make a major contribution to the implementation success of other regional projects that focus on aspects of ABM, e.g. SAPPHIRE and WIO-SAP. Total projected budget is $329,293 inclusive of 25% co-funding commitment from each partner organisation.
Project Objectives
Project Activities
1. Participatory mapping of coastal and marine planning systems: Implemented largely as planned, requiring adaptation to the methodology, specifically the use of online tools. 2.
Objective 2: Build a system dynamics model of key causalities in a changing climate: Partly implemented. Participatory model created online, but not a full systems dynamics mode.
Objective 3: Co-create climate services using system dynamic models: Co-creation of climate services is limited to discussion with ABM stakeholders on data and information needs, and the potential development of climate services to support local decision making
- Literature reviews of 1) legal and policy framework; 2) environmental and climate hazards; 3) stakeholders.
- Institutional analysis and stakeholder categorization Governance assessment of capacities for coastal and marine management and climate adaptation using a Capitals Approach Framework (CAF),
- Fuzzy Cognitive Mapping (FCM) exploring the relationships between the various CAF indicators [online]. and
- Workshop with key ABM stakeholders in Algoa Bay to explore the climate change data and information needs of actors (agencies, private sector and public sector) in the Algoa Bay area [in person/online];
Study Sites
Project Total Budget
Nelson Mandela Municipality and Nelson Mandela Bay
USD 330,000
Student Supported
Publication
1. Meredith Fernandes-Research Assistant nelson Mandela University. 2. Lena Rolfer- PhD Candidate GERICS
1. Celliers et al. Sans frontières – Ocean and Coastal Sustainability of the Western Indian Ocean (presented at the Nairobi Convention 2021 Science to Policy Platform Meeting, 23-25 March 2021).
2. Rölfer et al. Enabling climate resilience of coastal social-ecological systems through local coastal governance using the example of Algoa Bay, South Africa (presented at the WIOGEN Ocean Governance Conference, 27 – 29 October 2021).
3. Rivers et al. Institutional arrangements and agency within coastal area-based management in Algoa Bay, South Africa (in preparation)
4. Celliers et al. Stratification of institutions in a complex coastal system: implications for participatory processes (in preparation)
5. Rölfer et al. Stakeholder and network analysis for climate adaptation planning in coastal areas (in preparation)
6. Rosendo et al. Coastal and ocean governance in Algoa Bay, South Africa: a capitals approach to identifying barriers and opportunities for climate change adaptation (in preparation).
Reports
1. Cities & Climate Change in the Coastal Western Indian Ocean (CICLICO): Interim Report on recent findings from the CICLICO project: Jan 2020-August 2021(completed)
2. Report overview for Nelson Mandela Bay Municipality and Nelson Mandela University, Institute for Coastal and Marine Research Ocean Science Steering Committee (completed)
3. Response to a call at COP 26, CICLICO referred to as a project towards building resilient cities (sent to CBD), although not a focus of the brief the project is acknowledged and how it integrates into ocean governance approaches.
